UnAustralian Studies – Othered subjects and the media

​As always with writing about a culture that I did not grow up immersed in I may be misinformed about some of the cultural elements in this essay. I have aimed to research as best I could with the resources available to me with my looming deadlines. I am always open to corrections and notices of omission so just leave a comment if you have a deeper insight into these things than I do… It wouldn’t be hard.

Thanks

♡ Morgan

Map of the Murray to Mountains Rail Trail. Cartography by Steve Bennett, map data by OpenStreetMap contributors.

How does the Australian state exclude ‘othered’ subjects from the official body of the nation? http://wangarattachronicle.com.au/2013/03/25/fight-for-our-land/

The article that this essay will attempt to examine through the lens of the exclusion of ‘othered’ subjects from the Australian state concerns the recent spotlight on the contested Registered party status of the Yorta Yorta people of Warby Ovens National Park near Wangaratta Victoria. The Pangerang or Bangerang people are of a firm belief that they have the right to registered party status in this area and their representative in this article is elder Freddie Dowling who is voice the community’s disappointment and anger in reaction to the signs erected by Parks Victoria, claiming the site to be Yorta Yorta land. This article shows a distinct lack of understanding of the registered party process and displays problematic disconnects between the understanding of traditional custodianship and the formal government  measures in place for indigenous recognition.

The significance of the contested land is manifold but the key point of significance is a ceremonial and burial location located in the ranges and held by the Pangerang people as being of immense spiritual, cultural and historical value. The Yorta Yorta people do not appear to be contesting its significance to the people they refer to as the Bangerang, but rather have petitioned to represent them as part of their incorporated body, but as of this date this arrangement is not agreeable to the Pangerang people. The main issue at the heart of this is that in order to achieve recognition as a Registered Party for an area it is almost a necessity to have the backing of an incorporated body and legal expertise, meaning that smaller groups are unable to achieve the recognition of their historical entitlements without learning to work within a system of bureaucracy, a system that is borne out of the same government construct that robbed them of that entitlement in the first place. 

This article, in an effort to sensationalise the story by creating a sense of conflict between tangible people rather than people against an abstract concept such as a system has the effect of pitting people against people instead of holding the system to account:

“A FIGHT is heating up between the Pangerang and Yorta Yorta Aboriginal people over who are the rightful traditional owners of the Warby Ovens National Park.” (Morgan, 2013)

This statement puts the blame squarely at the feet of the Yorta Yorta people rather than questioning how a system of recognition could be so out of touch with indigenous concerns that it could allow this to happen.

Perhaps one of the most telling passages in the article is this: “Pangerang elder, Sandy Atkinson, said he contacted Aboriginal Affairs Minister, Jeanette Powell, last week to request a meeting so she would explain why Yorta Yorta has status as a Registered Aboriginal Party” (Morgan, 2013) in which an Aboriginal elder is having to ask why his people’s heritage is not recognised. This act by Sandy Atkinson of circumventing the mediation process with  the Yorta Yorta and going to the decision makers in the process is yet another indicator that the problem lies with the broken Registered Party system rather than  disagreements between Aboriginal groups. The argument for a policy of self determination of territory recognition is not raised in this, or any other article on the matter, despite the fact that self determination could go some way to unpicking some of the problems that the misguided Registered Party system has created (Huggins, 1998). The balance of power lies with those able to work within the government system and depicting the conflict as internal, when it is the imposition of laws by the state which has created the problem of incorrect recognition. This  creates an absence of cultural continuity, resulting in a living culture being treated as a dead culture or a culture existing purely in the past, thus robbing the issue of its immediacy and urgency. This problematic idea of indigenous identity as merely a matter of history undermines the genuine ties the Aboriginal people have to their traditional and cultural lands (Anderson, 1993). This dampening of the issue in the media and the public allows for the government to continue the oversimplification of  traditional indigenous custodianship, settling for systems of recognition that seem to be addressing the issue of Aboriginal land claims and rights without adequately reflecting the reality of those claims and rights or affording any power to the Aboriginal people themselves.

The claims to geographic and cartographic recognition is particularly important as it is one of the few avenues for recognition Aboriginal groups can access. Since colonization the culture and history of these communities has been systematically erased barring contemporary attempts to preserve a tiny fragment of what has been lost in the process of colonisation. The desire of the colonial powers and later the federated state powers to organise the vast landmass of Australia into a nation without a treaty or understanding of the original inhabitants meant that Aboriginal people have only a negligible voice in determining issues of legislation and law in determining place names, or preserving indigenous heritage. The impact of this is immeasurable, and the Pangerang people’s claim may come down to a map made in the 1860s (Douthie, 2016). 

This misnaming of important spaces is “symptomatic of forced colonization” (Anderson,1993) and is perpetuated by lost information and an unwillingness to change misinformation, which only serves as a continuation of power imbalance in Australia. This lack of emphasis on the correct recognition of pre-existing cultural and territorial history is a reflection of the racially biased way that legislative law works. Australia as a nation state is a potent symbolic force which carries with it ideas of stability and a kind of immovable structure that is resistant to change, particularly regarding issues surrounding reconciliation and power imbalances (Bhaba, 1991).

References
:

Anderson, Ian 1993, “Reclaiming Tru-ger-nan-ner: De-colonising the symbol” in Art Matters Monthly

Bhabha, H.K. 1991, “Introduction: Narrating the Nation” in Nation and Narration

Douthie, S. (2016). All in the name of the Pangerang tribe. Wangaratta Chronicle. Retrieved 22 June 2016, from http://wangarattachronicle.com.au/2016/04/11/all-in-the-name-of-the-pangerang-tribe/

Dowling, F. (2016). Pangerang Country with Freddie Dowling – Culture Victoria.Culture Victoria. Retrieved 22 June 2016, from http://www.cv.vic.gov.au/stories/aboriginal-culture/pangerang-country-with-freddie-dowling/

Huggins, Jackie, 1998, “Auntie Rita’s File”, in Sister Girl: The Writings of Aboriginal Activist and Historian (St. Lucia: University of Queensland Press), 131-134.

Martin, E. (2016). Department of Premier and Cabinet – Aboriginal Heritage Act 2006. Dpc.vic.gov.au. Retrieved 22 June 2016, from http://www.dpc.vic.gov.au/index.php/aboriginal-affairs/aboriginal-cultural-heritage/aboriginal-heritage-act-2006

Morgan, S. (2013). Fight for our land. Wangaratta Chronicle. Retrieved 22 June 2016, from http://wangarattachronicle.com.au/2013/03/25/fight-for-our-land/

The Shepparton Adviser – No recognition for traditional land owners. (2016). Sheppadviser.com.au. Retrieved 22 June 2016, from http://www.sheppadviser.com.au/no-recognition-for-traditional-land-owners/

Yorta Yorta blow-ins, says elder. (2011). The Border Mail. Retrieved 22 June 2016, from http://www.bordermail.com.au/story/59951/yorta-yorta-blow-ins-says-elder/
<a href=”http://www.bookdepository.com/?a_aid=morganmushroomwrites”>Buy Books From Book Depository So I can buy coffee!</a>

Advertisements

Bigfeet, bigfoots? All I know it’s sasquatchy in here

My enduring love of The Last Podcast on the Left is back. They have been doing CHAOS magic for the past few episodes and that is not really my jam. I know that a lot of people love the idea of being able to will the world to change through the power of their minds, but personally I quite prefer to think of myself as a bit of irrelevant flotsam floating about in an indifferent universe. There is something terribly comforting about knowing that my sphere of influence is incredibly finite. That means there is SO much less to stress about and nothing I can do about things out of my control. Enough with the navel gazing, back to upstanding hairy citizens on two feet. The new episode of Last Podcast is about the Bigfoot hunters; an electic pack (surely that is the collective noun in this case) of hunters, campers, anthropologists, weekend crypto zoologists, entrepreneurs and veterinarians who believe, in varying degrees, that bigfoots exist (yes this is the plural, I checked). I didn’t find anything particularly revelationary in the podcast but it tied up some of the loose ends in some of the more famous bigfoot research claims, which was pretty darn interesting.

Check it out here

AuthorGnashes30 wikicommons
Also as usual:

Buy Books From Book Depository So I can buy coffee!

Idiot puts cast iron pot in dishwasher.


Sets off ALL the fire alarms reseasoning zee bitch.

Using coconut oil to reseason my cast iron pot which has only seen one use. So the consensus seems to be

Step 1

Yell at whoever put it in the dishwasher 

Might skip this step as I was the dozy cow in question.

Step 2

Wipe off all rust with paper towel

I have no paper towel so I have substituted this with ruining a perfectly good tea towel 

Step 3

Coat pot in animal fat

Hmmn no…  reaches for coconut oil

Step 4 

Rub fat into pot

And face, and hair, and shirt.

Step 5

Cook at high temperature for 1 hour

… Or until neighbours call the fire brigade.

Repeat steps 1 to 5 until the people you are staying with because you are hairy interlopers kick you out… with good reason


Buy Books From Book Depository So I can buy coffee and expensive kitchenware to ruin!


Turtle house

Well things have taken a bit of a turn so at the moment we are hanging out in a caravan while we do up the bus. Its a tad chilly but we’re working hard to get it warm enough. Luckily we have some amazing friends who have given up way way too much of their personal space and driveway while we get sorted. Speaking of which if anyone has a nature strip or driveway we can seyt up on for a night please let us know, we are total freeloading hippies but can exchange driveway space for baby sitting, gardening or dog walking. Anyway as always sorry for not keeping everyone as updated as we should. We haven’t given up on the bus, our timeline has just changed.

Thanks to amazing people for continuing to be amazing.

Buy Books From Book Depository So I can buy coffee!

Another fairy story

​Once upon a time in a land where beachside resorts and sunshine abound an angry little woman spent her time dipping creatures of the sea and roots of the earth in boiling hot oil. This little woman had a lot to say about people that were different to her. She did not trust people who lived differently to her, in fact she feared them. So one day she set out for the land of roundabouts to tell everyone what she didn’t like about the people she didn’t understand. She made a lot of people very angry, but that only seemed to make her stronger and more relevant. She convinced the rulers of the land that what she had to say was popular and important. The more people tried to stop her from yelling and hurting people with words and legislation the more people she found who were just as hateful and bigoted as she was. But then, very slowly, people started ignoring her, and she shrank from viewing becoming almost completely irrelevant. But then the people who were in charge in the land of roundabouts stopped looking after the people and started arguing amongst themselves.

And gradually as if by magic, people started listening to the angry little woman again, she began to grown.

What happens next? Well that is up to us….

Buy Books From Book Depository So I can buy coffee!

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: